Psychological profiles of excluded living liver donor candidates An observational study

Living donor liver transplantation has advantages over deceased organ liver transplantation. However, the living liver donor candidates must be carefully assessed before surgery. Candidates may be excluded for various reasons. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the psychological profiles of excluded living liver donor candidates according to the reason for exclusion. A descriptive and cross-sectional study was conducted. Donor candidates were invited to participate if they were at least 20 years of age, related biologically or by marriage to the recipient (within 5 degrees), and had undergone living donor evaluation. Among the 338 participants recruited from August 2013 to December 2015, 116 were excluded for the following reasons: a medical condition (n=35), failure to be chosen (n=63), or withdrawal from the selection process (n=18). The psychological profiles of these 3 exclusion groups were evaluated. There were no significant group differences in age, sex, education level, religion, marital status, and consanguinity (P>.05). The withdrawal group had fewer recipients with an hepatitis B virus infection than did the other groups (x²=9.28, P=.01). Additionally, compared with the unchosen group, the withdrawal group had lower intimacy with the recipient (F=5.32, P=.006) and higher ambivalence (F=5.53, P=.005). In terms of family relationship parameters, the withdrawal group had lower family cohesion than the medical condition and unchosen groups (F=4.44, P=.01), lower family expressiveness than the medical condition group (F=3.76, P=.03), and higher family conflict than the medical condition and unchosen groups (F=7.05, P=.001). The withdrawal group also had lower emotional social support than the medical condition group (F=3.55, P=.03). There were no significant group difference in motivation, expectations, donation-related concerns, informational social support, value social support, instrumental social support, and health-related quality of life. The living donor candidates who withdrew from the selection process had obvious ambivalence, poorer family relationships, and insufficient emotional social support. The transplantation team should respect the autonomy of the candidate's decision and mitigate the impact of the donation decision on living liver donor candidates.